How to choose the right iPod in 2025
Article recap: For an easy, reliable choice, pick the iPod Video 5th generation (preferably look for a 5.5th generation). The 6th generation is a solid in-between, but comes with some charging issues. For the freshest “out of the box” feel, the 7th generation iPod Classic 160 GB is an excellent choice.
Quick comparison: iPod Classic generations
| Model | Notable features | Original storage | Mod potential | Common problems |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| iPod Video 5th generation | Released late 2005 Model A1136 32MB RAM on 30GB models Wolfson DAC |
30/60 GB | Easy to open Up to 2TB storage if 64MB RAM (60GB model) |
32MB RAM can cause trouble when dealing with libraries upwards of 20-30,000 songs (300GB ish). |
| iPod Video 5.5th generation ‘Enhanced’ | Released late 2006 Model A1136 32MB RAM on 30GB models Added search feature and brighter screen Wolfson DAC |
30/80 GB | Easy to open Up to 2TB storage if 64MB RAM (80GB model) |
32MB RAM can cause trouble when dealing with libraries upwards of 20-30,000 songs (300GB ish). |
| iPod Classic 6th generation | Released 2007 Model A1238 80/120/160 GB 160 GB has thick backplate Cirrus Logic DAC |
80/120/160 GB | Capped at 128 GB storage when flash modding with stock OS. Can be bypassed. | Picky with many wall chargers But charges from most PC USB portsHarder to open compared to the 5th generation. |
| iPod Classic 7th generation | Released late 2009 Model A1238 Thin 160 GB Cirrus Logic DAC |
160 GB (thin) | Up to 2TB storage on any model. Snappier UI (good for large libraries) |
Harder to open compared to the 5th generation. |
Which iPod Classic is right for you?
Choose the iPod Video 5th generation if you want the safe bet
- The most mod-friendly device – especially the 5.5th generation
- Easy to identify once you know the key differences between 5th and 5.5th generation (read more below)
- Benefits from a huge pool of parts, tutorials, and community troubleshooting support
Choose the iPod Classic 6th generation if you want the modern design at a lower price
- The 6th generation is not as pricey as the 7th generation due to less interest from the modding community
- There’s a new method to bypass the 128 GB limit by flashing to a custom firmware. This allows for large flash modifications while running iPod OS
- Downside: The 6th generation is known for not charging with many wall adapters. It typically charges reliably from a PC USB port
Choose the iPod Classic 7th generation if you want the premium experience
- Features a thin 160 GB design straight out of the box, a premium finish, and a snappy user interface
- Offers ample flash-mod headroom if you decide you need more capacity later on. Up to 2TB without tinkering with iPod OS
Quick guide to differentiating iPod Classic models
iPod Video 5th generation vs. 5th generation Enhanced
The 5.5th generation (late 2006) includes a “Search” option in the main menu, has a noticeably brighter screen, and was available in an 80 GB variant. The original 5th generation (late 2005) lacks the “Search” feature, has a slightly dimmer screen, and came in 30 GB and 60 GB sizes.
Both models share the A1136 model number, so checking the menu and screen brightness is crucial. It can be hard when looking at eBay etc. and sometimes sellers have left out images of these features. In that case, look for 5.5th generation by checking the serial number found on the backplate that ends in: V9K, V9L, V9M, V9N, V9P, V9Q or V9R.
Full 5th vs 5.5th generation identification guide coming soon.
iPod Classic 6th generation 160 GB vs. 7th generation 160 GB
The 2007 160 GB model (6th generation) is thicker than the 2009 160 GB model (7th generation), which is thin. Both share the A1238 model number, so use thickness and the production year to differentiate. Additionally, the storage engraving on the back is noticeably larger on the 6th generation.
Why the 6th generation can be picky with wall chargers
The iPod Classic 6th generation requires specific voltages on the USB data pins before it will initiate charging. Many generic wall adapters don’t provide these specific voltages, causing the iPod to refuse to charge. Charging from a PC USB port typically works without issues. A small “trigger” adapter, placed in-line with your USB cable, usually resolves wall charging problems.
Our final recommendation
Our Top Pick: The iPod Video 5.5th generation.
Premium feel at a lower price: The iPod Classic 6th generation — but only if you’re not interested in modding the storage or are ready to take on the firmware flash to overcome the 128 GB storage ceiling.
Premium Daily Driver: The iPod Classic 7th generation thin 160 GB model.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
What’s the single best iPod Classic to buy in 2025?
For most people, the iPod Video 5th generation is the best choice. It’s easy to modify, simple to service, and has excellent community documentation.
For a more premium device, the iPod Classic 7th generation is a really good purchase.
Can a 6th generation iPod Classic go past 128 GB?
Yes, it can, by utilizing a newly discovered firmware method that allows you to flash custom Classic firmware. Without this method, the stock firmware limits flash modifications to around 128 GB.
Why won’t my 6th generation iPod Classic charge from a wall adapter?
The 6th generation iPod Classic is particular about the USB data pins. Using a PC USB port or a small, in-line trigger adapter will typically allow it to charge without issues.
Is the 7th generation iPod Classic worth it over a 6th generation?
If you desire the space gray color option and snappier software, then yes. The iPod Classic 7th generation model offers a slicker user interface and a premium feel.
How do I tell a 5th generation iPod from a 5.5th generation?
Look for the “Search” menu option and the 80 GB variant, plus its brighter screen. The 5th generation lacks “Search,” has a slightly dimmer screen, and came in 30 GB/60 GB. Full guide coming soon.
Also, the serial number found on the backplate should end in either: V9K, V9L, V9M, V9N, V9P, V9Q or V9R.